610-459-9646
sales@sciotex.com

Custom Automation Equipment vs Off-the-Shelf Machines: How to Decide

Written by Sciotex Engineering
In this article

Custom automation equipment is machinery designed and built for one specific process, part or line, rather than chosen from a catalog. Every manufacturer that automates eventually faces the same question: buy a standard machine, or have one built? This article compares custom and off-the-shelf equipment, explains when each is the right call, and covers the hybrid options that often give the best of both.

What counts as custom automation equipment

  • Fully custom machines: designed from scratch around a part or process no standard machine handles.
  • Custom cells: standard components such as robots, cameras and conveyors, engineered into a system built for your application.
  • Modified standard machines: a catalog platform with custom fixtures, tooling, software or data connections.

Custom vs off-the-shelf automation compared

Off-the-shelf machineCustom automation equipment
FitYou adapt the process to the machineBuilt around your parts, rate and footprint
Upfront costUsually lowerHigher engineering content
Lead timeShorter, often from stock or standard buildLonger; design, build and test
Technical riskLow for jobs the machine was made forManaged through feasibility testing and phased design
IntegrationMay need adapting to your line and data systemsDesigned to fit your line, controls and data
Change over timeLimited to what the product supportsDesigned for your part variety and future changes
SupportVendor product supportThe team that built it supports it

When off-the-shelf is the right answer

Buy standard when the job is common and well defined, the machine has a track record on parts like yours, and it fits your line without major changes. Proven standard equipment costs less, arrives sooner and is easier to support. A good integrator will tell you when a catalog machine is the better answer.

When custom automation pays off

  • No standard machine handles your part: odd shapes, fragile or mixed parts, tight tolerances or very high speeds
  • The station must fit an existing line, conveyor or tight footprint
  • Several steps, such as inspection, counting and test, need to happen in one cell
  • Results must flow to your database, MES or quality records in a set format
  • A standard machine would need so much rework that it becomes custom anyway
  • The process itself is your competitive advantage and not something to share with a machine vendor

The hybrid option: standard platforms, custom where it counts

Many of the best projects sit between the two: a proven standard platform with custom fixtures, software or data connections. The platform carries the reliability and cost advantage of standard equipment; the custom work makes it fit your parts and your plant.

Sciotex builds this way where it fits. The PerfectCount counting machine comes in three standard sizes plus custom options, and the benchtop inspection platforms are configured for each customer’s parts. Robotic systems, by contrast, are mostly custom.

How custom automation equipment is designed and built

Step 1
Requirements
Process analysis, rate, accuracy, part variety, footprint, safety and data.
Step 2
Feasibility
Tests on real production samples to prove the approach.
Step 3
Design
Mechanical, electrical, controls and software design, reviewed in phases.
Step 4
Build
Fabrication, panel build, programming and integration.
Step 5
Test and install
Factory and site acceptance tests, then training and support.

How to reduce the risk of a custom build

  • Test real parts before committing to the design. For inspection projects, Sciotex tests sample parts free of charge.
  • Use proven components wherever possible; keep custom engineering for where it adds value.
  • Agree written acceptance criteria and test against them at FAT and SAT.
  • Review the design in phases, with decision points before major spending.
  • Make sure documentation and software are handed over so the system can be supported long term.
Weighing a custom build? Sciotex is an industrial automation company that has designed and built custom automation since 1997, and will tell you when a standard machine is the better choice.

Frequently asked questions

What is custom automation equipment?

Machinery designed and built for a specific process, part or line rather than chosen from a catalog. It ranges from fully custom machines to standard platforms with custom fixtures, software or data connections.

Is custom automation more expensive than off-the-shelf?

Upfront cost is usually higher because of the engineering involved. It can still cost less overall when a standard machine would need heavy modification, would not fit the line, or would not handle your parts reliably.

When should I choose custom automation?

When no standard machine handles your parts, the station must fit an existing line or footprint, several steps must be combined in one cell, or results must integrate with your data systems in a specific way.

How do you reduce the risk of custom automation?

Test real parts early, use proven components, set written acceptance criteria, review the design in phases, and make sure software and documentation are handed over.

Related articles

Written by

Sciotex Engineering

The Sciotex engineering team has designed and built automation, vision and test systems since 1997.

Have an automation project to plan?

Talk it through with a Sciotex engineer.

In this article
Planning an automation project?

Talk it through with a Sciotex engineer.

Next step

See what custom automation could do on your line