Choosing an industrial automation company is the decision that most shapes how an automation project turns out. The same idea, built by two different partners, can become a station that runs for a decade or one that gets pushed into a corner after six months. This checklist covers the 12 things worth researching before you hire an automation company or systems integrator, plus the questions to ask and the warning signs to watch for.
It is written for manufacturers who are buying custom automation: inspection, counting, test, data acquisition, process control or robotic handling that no catalog machine fully covers. If you are still deciding what automation is right for your plant, start with the industrial automation guide.
First, know which kind of automation company you need
“Automation company” covers very different businesses, and contacting the wrong kind wastes weeks of quoting.
| Type | What they do | Choose them when |
|---|---|---|
| Component manufacturers | Make PLCs, drives, robots, sensors and cameras | Your own engineers will design and integrate the system |
| Machine builders | Sell standard machines configured from options | The job is common and a catalog machine fits |
| Systems integrators | Engineer a custom system from proven components and take responsibility for it working | Your parts, rate, footprint or data needs fall outside standard machines |
| Engineering consultancies | Study, specify and manage projects that others build | You have in-house build capacity and need specification help |
Most custom automation projects need a systems integrator, ideally one that can also supply standard platforms where they fit. The rest of this checklist assumes that is what you are looking for.
Why use an automation company instead of doing it in-house?
Plant engineering teams are usually fully loaded keeping production running. A specialist automation company brings people who design these systems every week, a tested process, and the mechanical, electrical, controls and software skills under one roof. You also get one party accountable for the result, rather than coordinating separate vendors for the machine, the controls and the software.
Doing it in-house can make sense for simple, repeatable projects where your team already has the skills. For anything new to your plant, the cost of a learning curve on the production floor usually outweighs the savings.
12 things to research when choosing an automation company
1. Experience with your application
Ask for systems they have built that are close to yours: similar parts, rates, tolerances or environments. Real examples matter more than a long capability list. An integrator who has solved your type of problem before will spot risks you have not thought of yet.
2. Whether they test your parts before quoting
The surest way to remove risk is to prove the approach on your actual parts. A good partner will run feasibility tests on production samples, especially for inspection and counting, where part variation decides what works. At Sciotex, sample-part testing for inspection projects is free of charge.
3. A phased project process
Look for clear phases with deliverables you can review: requirements, design, build, factory acceptance test (FAT), site acceptance test (SAT) and training. Phases give you decision points before the big costs are committed.
4. In-house engineering disciplines
Custom automation needs mechanical, electrical, controls and software engineering working together. Partners who subcontract half of that add hand-offs, and hand-offs are where projects slip. Ask who will actually do each part of the work.
5. Software quality, documentation and ownership
Software is where custom automation differs most and where you will live with the result longest. Ask how software is structured, documented and handed over, what you will own at the end, and how easy it will be for your team to change recipes or add part numbers.
6. Fit with your platforms
The system has to work with the PLCs, robots, databases and MES you already run. Ask which platforms they integrate with and whether they will follow your plant standards. Sciotex integrates with most major hardware and software platforms and is an NI and LabVIEW integrator.
7. Data, traceability and reporting
Modern stations produce useful data: results per part, images, counts and trends. Decide early what records you need and confirm the partner can deliver them in the format your quality and production teams use.
8. Safety and standards
Ask how they handle machine guarding, risk assessment and the safety standards your plant follows. A partner who treats safety as part of design, not an add-on at the end, avoids costly rework at installation.
9. Clear acceptance criteria
Agree in writing how success will be measured: rate, accuracy, false reject rate, uptime and data delivered. Then make sure FAT and SAT test against exactly those criteria.
10. The support model
Find out what happens after installation: response times, remote support, spare parts and help with new part numbers. Check whether support requires a subscription or contract. Working with Sciotex does not require a subscription or support contract.
11. References and repeat customers
Repeat customers are the best evidence of a good partner. Ask for references in your industry, and ask those references what went wrong and how it was handled, not just whether they were happy.
12. Total cost, not just price
Compare total cost: engineering, equipment, integration, installation downtime, training and support, set against the savings the system delivers. The lowest quote often leaves out the work that decides whether the system succeeds. See how to calculate automation ROI and budgeting for industrial automation projects.
Questions to ask on the first call
| Question | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| What similar systems have you built? | Shows real experience with your application |
| Can you test our sample parts first? | Removes the biggest technical risk before you commit |
| Who does the mechanical, electrical and software work? | Reveals subcontracting and hand-off risk |
| How will acceptance be measured? | Sets clear success criteria for FAT and SAT |
| What do we own and receive at handover? | Protects your ability to support and change the system |
| What does support look like after installation? | Avoids surprises on cost and response time |
Red flags
- A firm price before anyone has seen your parts or process
- No examples close to your application
- Vague answers about who writes the software
- No written acceptance criteria
- Support that only works through a mandatory contract
- Pressure to commit before feasibility is proven
Frequently asked questions
Start by deciding whether you need a component supplier, a machine builder or a systems integrator. Then check experience with your application, willingness to test your parts, a phased process with clear acceptance criteria, in-house engineering, software quality, platform fit and the support model.
“Automation company” is a broad label that includes component makers and machine builders. A systems integrator engineers a custom system from proven components and takes responsibility for it working in your plant.
In-house can work for simple, repeatable projects where your team already has the skills. For new or complex automation, an integrator usually delivers faster and with less risk, because they design these systems routinely.
Scope, requirements, the proposed design approach, acceptance criteria, what is included in installation and training, what you will own at handover, the support model and a schedule with review points.
Related articles
- Industrial Automation: A Practical Guide to Manufacturing Automation
- Automation ROI: How to Calculate Payback on Manufacturing Automation
- What to Automate First: How to Pick the Best Automation Targets
- Custom Automation Equipment vs Off-the-Shelf Machines
- Top 10 US Manufacturing Companies Leading the Automation Revolution
- Industrial Automation Consultants: When and How to Hire One