Cost of Poor Quality: How to Measure What Defects Really Cost

Written by Sciotex Engineering
In this article

The cost of poor quality (COPQ) is everything a plant spends because products aren’t made right the first time: scrap and rework inside the plant, returns, credits and sorting at the customer, and the cost of inspecting to catch defects. For most manufacturers it is several percent of sales, and much of it is hidden in labor and overhead that nobody labels as quality cost.

This article is part of our machine vision guide. It shows how to put a number on poor quality for an inspection problem, which is usually the first step in a continuous improvement or automation business case.

In short

  • COPQ has four buckets: internal failure, external failure, appraisal and prevention.
  • Inspection labor is appraisal cost: real money that adds no value.
  • External failures cost the most per defect and hurt the customer relationship.
  • A credible COPQ estimate needs only a few plant numbers.

The four categories of quality cost

CategoryWhat it includesInspection example
Internal failureScrap, rework, retest, downtime caused by defectsParts scrapped after a defect is found at final inspection
External failureReturns, credits, sorting at the customer, warranty, expedited freightA customer finds a missing component and returns the lot
AppraisalInspection, testing, audits, gauge calibrationInspectors checking every part by eye
PreventionTraining, error proofing, process design, supplier qualityDesigning an automated check at the station where errors occur

The first three are the cost of poor quality. Prevention is the investment that reduces them. Spending on prevention usually brings the total down.

Worked example: an inspection-heavy line

These numbers are illustrative. Replace them with your own plant data.

Cost itemAssumptionAnnual cost
Inspection labor (appraisal)3 inspectors × 2 shifts × 8 hours × 250 days at $25/hour$300,000
Scrap (internal failure)1.5% of 1,000,000 parts at $2 each in material and labor$30,000
Customer complaints (external failure)12 complaints a year at $4,000 each in sorting, freight and credits$48,000
Total cost of poor quality$378,000

Two things stand out. Inspection labor is the largest item, and it is spent to catch defects rather than prevent them. And the external failures, though the smallest number here, carry the cost that never shows on a spreadsheet: a customer who starts looking for a second supplier.

How to gather the numbers

  • Inspection labor: people and hours spent inspecting, sorting and re-inspecting, at a loaded labor rate.
  • Scrap and rework: from your scrap log or MRP, valued at material plus labor added so far.
  • External failures: from complaint and return records: credits, freight, sorting charges and the hours your team spends responding.
  • Escapes: defects found by the customer per million parts shipped. This tells you how well the current inspection works.

If the data doesn’t exist, a two-week sample of inspection hours and defect counts is usually enough for a first estimate.

Using COPQ to justify automation

Automated inspection and error proofing reduce COPQ in three ways: they move inspection labor to work that needs people, they catch defects earlier when they are cheaper, and they cut escapes. The savings case compares the COPQ you can remove with the cost of the system. For the full return calculation, see automated inspection ROI.

Be conservative. Count only the costs the system will actually remove, and keep any inspection you will still need for audits or regulatory reasons.

Want to see what your defects are costing?

Sciotex helps manufacturers quantify inspection problems and designs automated inspection systems to remove them, with free testing of your sample parts. Vision systems typically pay back in 7–12 months.

Explore automated inspection

Frequently asked questions

What is the cost of poor quality?

The cost of poor quality is the total cost of not making products right the first time: internal failures such as scrap and rework, external failures such as returns and credits, and appraisal costs such as inspection.

What are the four categories of quality cost?

Internal failure, external failure, appraisal and prevention. The first three make up the cost of poor quality; prevention is the investment that reduces it.

Is inspection part of the cost of poor quality?

Yes. Inspection is an appraisal cost: it is spent to find defects rather than prevent them, so it is usually counted in the cost of poor quality.

How do you calculate the cost of poor quality?

Add up inspection and testing labor, scrap and rework, and external failure costs such as credits, freight and sorting, using a loaded labor rate and your scrap and complaint records.

How does automation reduce the cost of poor quality?

It catches defects earlier and more consistently, cuts escapes to customers, and frees inspection labor for work that needs people.

Related articles

Written by

Sciotex Engineering

The Sciotex engineering team has designed and built vision, automation and test systems since 1997.

Have an inspection problem to solve?

Talk it through with a Sciotex engineer.

In this article
Have an inspection problem to solve?

Talk it through with a Sciotex engineer.

Next step

See what a vision system could do on your line